Sunday, January 8, 2012

Addressing Inequality: Is Government the Answer?


Inequality is finally, mercifully, a topic of common concern. Articles are regularly popping up in the mainstream media, expressing relief at our newfound willingness to address the topic, from people who had a platform for addressing such issues well before the Occupy movement did.
Lately these articles seem to support a common premise: Inequality is driven by complex forces some of which are, to quote Globe and Mail columnist Jeffrey Simpson, “beyond the reach of government.”
Technology and globalization are most often singled out as examples of these forces. From global editor-at-large Chrystia Freeland of Reuters, “[Rapidly rising inequality] is the consequence of a massive – and broadly positive – economic transformation … the big drivers are the twin revolutions reshaping the world economy – globalization and new technology.” From Vancouver Sun columnist Craig McInnes, “Why are we working harder and earning less? … technological change and globalization.”
Certainly, technology and globalization – if they can be so neatly separated for analytical sake – are playing a major role in structuring the world. But instead of simply suggesting that this explanation is “politically inconvenient,” as Freeland does, we need to take a careful look at how government shapes, is shaped by, and responds to these forces.
Globalization and technological change are the result of our collective actions. So, we need to remember, is government. It doesn’t take much to realize that very selective, government-driven trade liberalization is a key component of globalization. Government decisions to enter trade deals also coincided with decisions to de-fund education and social services – to ignore the effect that both globalization and technology would have on the working class, who faced either a transition into high-skilled labour, or the decline into informal and low-paying service-sector jobs that has gutted wages on the lower end of the spectrum.



Related: Questioning the Merits of Globalization


To be clear, looking back to government doesn’t mean blind support for the postwar consensus model of big government. It’s past time for us to innovate beyond that model, – not by abandoning the idea of government, but by being both imaginative and pragmatic about what it can look like in a networked society. Abandoning the idea that government – which, we easily forget, can simply mean the body of people who make and enforce laws, a body we are all potentially part of – can solve problems is some of what has gotten us into this mess of inequality in the first place.
When people are increasingly in dire need, we should be loath to see government get smaller. Even many economists would agree with this statement. Instead we should focus on seeing how it can become more open, more democratic, and more widely distributed. Words like “capitalism,” “socialism,” or “anarchism” have utterly failed to help all of us come together to agree on what a more equitable distribution of governing powers might look like.
Looking to government is essential if we want a meaningful democracy that combats inequality. So is re-conceiving what government means to us. What we’re learning from this crisis and the response of Occupy movements is that “grassroots” democracy is the logical response to political systems that have lost touch with the body politic. That lesson is long overdue.
What we may be learning, too, is that democracy at a “grassroots” level is the only real kind of democracy, since the alternative – representative and bureaucratic – has failed to meet the basic condition of striving to serve all people equally. The postwar consensus was fantastic for producing a large middle class – a great achievement – but let’s not forget that it still left a marginalized underclass who were alienated both from and by the bureaucratic structures of a centralized government.



Related: Some Accountability, Please


That bureaucracy, which is more easily navigated and manipulated by those with power and resources than by anyone else, has also contributed to the creation of a dominant class who can curse and cajole the state into doing its bidding. This undermines democracy. That shouldn’t shock us, as former American president Franklin Roosevelt predicted it in 1938 and former president Thomas Jefferson predicted it almost 200 years ago.
Globalization and technology have helped produce such shocking inequality in large part because the policies that shape the development of these two forces have systematically been made through bureaucratic processes that exclude and alienate the “grassroots.” As a result, “public” policy has failed to prioritize the public good. Turning away from government now because of the complexity or inconvenience of these two forces would only increase their negative effects.
Inequality cannot be addressed without confronting complex technological and globalizing forces – forces that both drive, and are driven by, government policies. If we ignore either of those realities, we’re mystifying a conversation that desperately calls for clarity. Let’s focus like a laser on re-imagining what democratic government looks like by returning to the pure and simple roots of the concept: equal participation in making laws and policies that leave us free to flourish, that help refine and articulate our notion of and commitment to the public good. Almost nothing is beyond the reach of this force.

[VIDEO] The Battle Against Blood Diamonds


The Kimberley Process, which established an international certification scheme once admired for successfully filtering conflict diamonds out of circulation, has recently come under fire for overlooking certain human rights abuses. Ignoring the violent conflict surrounding Zimbabwe's diamond exports has damaged its legitimacy and led to various member states pulling out of the agreement in protests.

Canadian Public Diplomacy, Then and Now


I have recently been reviewing Diplomacy in the Digital Age, a collection of essays prepared in honour of Allan Gotlieb, a former Undersecretary of State for External Affairs and Canada’s ambassador in Washington from 1981-89. It is an absorbing anthology, and contains valuable entries, penned, in some instances, by those who worked with Gotlieb during his time in the U.S. Quite apart from eliciting specific reactions to the content of the volume, reading it has also spurred me to reflect on the larger issue of what became of Canada’s once considerable contribution to the study and practice of public diplomacy (PD).
The Government of Canada was, until fairly recently, regarded as somewhat of a PD pioneer. That reputation would now be difficult to sustain. Indeed, I have come to the rather stark realization that, whatever this country may at one time have achieved by way of advancing its interests through PD, those days are now long gone.
In official and political circles in Ottawa today, little or nothing is heard of PD. The practice, and even the use of the term, has been discouraged within the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade (DFAIT), and the function has been almost completely de-resourced.



Related: Diplomacy, Journalism, and the New Media


Hence, the questions must be put: What, exactly, did Canada manage to achieve in terms of PD outcomes over the past several decades? Why has PD fallen from grace? And, finally, can any lessons of broader relevance be adduced?
Canadian academics, and several serving and former diplomats, have, over time, been active in the conceptualization and analysis of PD. Publications such as Allan Gotlieb’s I'll Be With You in a Minute, Mr. Ambassador, Gordon Smith’s Virtual Diplomacy, Rob McRae and Don Hubert’s Human Security and the New Diplomacy, Andy Cooper’s Celebrity Diplomacy, Evan Potter’s Branding Canada, and perhaps even my own Guerrilla Diplomacy have been seen by some as breaking new ground in the field.
In addition to these intellectual contributions, the Canadian foreign ministry has been deeply involved in the practical application of PD. Beginning in the 1980s, most of Canada’s major diplomatic undertakings – the 1981 Cancun Summit on North-South relations, former prime minister Pierre Trudeau’s 1984 peace crusade, the acid-rain and free-trade pacts with the U.S., the 1987 Montreal Protocol on ozone-layer depletion, and the Commonwealth campaign to end apartheid in southern Africa – included a significant PD component. Even if not labelled as public diplomacy at the time, a willingness to connect directly with foreign populations, the strategic use of the media, and tactics such as forging partnerships with business and civil society were integral to each of these initiatives.
In the early 1990s, and quite explicitly so by the second half of the decade, PD moved even closer to the centre of Canadian international policy. In the organization and delivery of the 1992 Rio Summit on Environment and Development, throughout the so-called “fish war” with Spain in 1994, and particularly during Lloyd Axworthy’s four-year tenure as foreign minister (1996-2000), PD, and the related notion of “soft power,” were the order of the day.



Related: Hard Power Vs. Soft Power


Charged with implementing the severe expenditure reductions associated with the government-wide Program Review exercise of the mid-1990s, Axworthy must have concluded that the page had to be turned on old ways, and that global order projects would accordingly have to be set aside. But he was clearly not prepared to accept that this meant inaction. To the contrary, he demanded that DFAIT officials identify innovative ways for Canada to “make a difference.” He was determined to find opportunity in adversity, even if faced with opposition from the U.S. and other major powers, and, indeed, from many Canadians.
DFAIT staff rose to the challenge, and came forth with a series of proposals. In the campaigns leading to the signature of the Treaty Banning Land Mines in 1997 and the establishment of the International Criminal Court in 1998, Axworthy attained his objectives by nurturing partnerships with international civil society and similarly inclined countries. He also reached out in an unprecedented fashion to the journalists, the academic community, and NGOs at home, mainly through the creation of the Canadian Centre for Foreign Policy Development and the Public Diplomacy Fund at DFAIT.
The same approach, in varying degrees, was seen in initiatives intended to limit the spread of small arms, to underscore the plight of children in war zones and curb the use of child soldiers, and to restrict the sale of “conflict diamonds” through the launch of the Kimberly Process. Canada also sponsored the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, whose final report, “The Responsibility to Protect,” though initially overtaken by the events of 9/11, resurfaced and was adopted in principle at the UN Millennium Summit in September 2005.
Taken together, Axworthy’s achievements were artfully – and, in part, retrospectively – packaged by officials into a remarkably coherent program, which came to be known as the Human Security Agenda. Although that policy direction did not survive for long following the minister’s departure from office, the record of activity in the second half of the 1990s stands nonetheless as an enduring testament to the power and potential of Canadian PD. It was a high point that has not been revisited since. To a significant extent, I would suggest that, whatever remains, Canada’s positive international reputation – its brand – still relies on these, and earlier accomplishments.
Photo courtesy of Reuters.

Saturday, January 7, 2012

Canadians Take on the Globe


Canadians certainly made a mark on the international circuit this year. It wasn't just Mark Carney, Peter Kent, John Baird and Prime Minister Harper driving the international conversation. So too were Canadian authors, whose books on international affairs influenced global discussions about aid, Islam, India, global cities, digital diplomacy, Afghanistan - and even Mount Everest.
The Mark is pleased to feature OpenCanada's list of some of the best international affairs books by Canadians this year (in no particular order). In addition, they ask each author to name what they think to be the biggest international event of 2011, the biggest international influencer of 2011, and Canada's best and worst moments this year. Some say Kyoto was Canada's best moment, others its worst. In addition, OpenCanada asks each author six telling questions:
  1. What is the best international affairs book you have read in 2011 (Canadian or otherwise?)
  2. What was the biggest international event of 2011?
  3. Who was the biggest international influencer of 2011?
  4. Who was the biggest Canadian international influencer of 2011?
  5. What was Canada’s best international moment of 2011?
  6. What was Canada’s worst international moment of 2011?
Some say Kyoto was Canada's best moment, others its worst. To see the list, and where Canada's international literary crew agree and disagree, click here or on the image below.