Friday, January 6, 2012

When Religion Trumps Free Inquiry


The photos could likely pass as authentic if they weren’t so shocking. The affection looks genuine; lip-locked passion in all its glory. The images that Benetton, an Italian fashion giant, used in its latest international advertising campaign are clearly doctored, but the controversy they stirred is certainly real.
Images from the company’s “Unhate” campaign spread in November, attracting the attention of media outlets worldwide. They were all there – Barack Obama and Hu Jintao, Angela Merkel and Nicolas Sarkozy, Benjamin Netanyahu and Mahmoud Abbas – each in a distinct, but equally amorous, embrace. But the most controversial image, or at least the one that garnered the most backlash, was the one depicting Pope Benedict XVI mashing lips with prominent Egyptian Imam Ahmed Mohamed el-Tayeb (the Imam looked to be the better kisser). Known for its intolerance of homosexuality and “defamation,” the Vatican retaliated almost immediately, declaring the image an “entirely unacceptable use of a manipulated image of the Holy Father, used as part of a publicity campaign which has commercial ends.”
We have a hard time believing that the reaction would have been different if the image were published for non-commercial purposes, but Benetton’s ends are irrelevant. So is the fact that the Vatican may have reacted out of an age-old squeamishness (read: hatred) toward homosexuality. Intolerance is traditional papal doctrine in a nutshell, and homosexuality is Exhibit A – alongside the Vatican’s positions on abortion and contraception, its stubborn history of anti-Semitism, and its seemingly incurable phobia of the freedom of inquiry. More concerning than the papal peevishness with which we have all become accustomed is how the “secular” world reacts, and has traditionally reacted, to it. Benetton quickly withdrew the image in question from its campaign and issued a profuse apology to the Catholic community after the Vatican released a statement condemning the ad as damaging “to the feelings of believers.”



Related: Benetton Kissing Campaign Upsets Vatican


Interestingly, a spokesperson for the White House also expressed discontent with the publication of a photo of President Obama, citing the White House’s “longstanding policy disapproving of the use of the president's name and likeness for commercial purposes.” But the Obama image remains.
While such preferential treatment is not new, its continued practice serves to embolden the religious and erode secular values of free speech and freedom of the press. On what grounds do religious figures claim immunity from criticism not afforded to other world leaders? Let us remember that the Vatican is a state, under observer status at the United Nations, and that the Pope is thus a head of state. It is for this reason that author Richard Dawkins and others considered petitioning the International Criminal Court to issue a warrant for the Pope’s arrest after it was alleged that he had been complicit in the sexual assault of children by clergymen.
Religious figures of all stripes have been complicit in, and responsible for, innumerable atrocities, the child-abuse scandal being the most recent Catholic example. The rise of Islamic extremism has exacerbated (and perhaps been exacerbated by) a number of conflicts in the Middle East, Africa, and parts of Europe during the last 30 years. Fear of reprisal has made criticism of Islam more and more taboo in the western world, to the point that airing a cartoon of the Prophet Mohammed – even dressed in a bear costume – may be taking one’s life into one’s hands.
The papacy, for its part, has reacted to such extremism in recent decades by routinely siding with religion. The Vatican tacitly accepted a fatwa (religious decree) that Iran’s former leader, Ayatollah Khomeini, issued in 1989 against author Salman Rushdie in response to The Satanic Verses, condemning not the threat on Rushdie’s life, but the novel itself. The current Pope, arguably more reactionary than his predecessor, chose to condemn the above-mentioned infamous Danish cartoons depicting the Prophet Mohammed – which are considered blasphemous in Islam – just as Islamist groups issued death threats to journalists and protesters stormed Danish and other western embassies.



Related: Religious Freedom, Compliments of the West


Benetton’s decision to remove the Pope’s image is a reminder of just how effectively religious figures can – forgive the phrasing – put the fear of God in us. Religions and their institutions are powerful players on the world stage and exert considerable influence in the public realm. But this is no excuse for the kind of complicity we see. The secular world bears responsibility for its misguided permission of religion’s self-proclaimed special status. Western heads of state also criticized Rushdie’s novel, while bookstores took it off their shelves. Media outlets apologized for the existence of the Danish cartoons, and refused to reprint them. The only Canadian with the chutzpah to reprint the cartoons was controversial writer Ezra Levant. We need to ask ourselves what kind of message this sends. What is free speech if it is only free so far as it does not offend the pious?
Benetton had it right the first time. Its biggest failure in handling the ad scandal was capitulation to those that claim immunity from public mockery because they are "people of faith." Benetton grovelled the way so many, including us in Canada, have done before. Shame on them. Shame on us.
Photo courtesy of Reuters.

Solving Syria

AppId is over the quota
AppId is over the quota
type="html">

***Visit the new CIC website at OpenCanada.Org. Canada's hub for international affairs.


The Arab League’s monitoring mission to Syria is facing a legitimacy crisis. While the secretary general of the League, Nabil Elaraby, claims the mission has helped persuade the embattled Syrian regime to release political prisoners and pull tanks back from city centres, critics contend that the monitors are colluding with the government to cover up the killing of protesters. Some organizations, such as Amnesty International, have gone even further, arguing that the mission chief – senior Sudanese military officer Mustafa al-Dabi – cannot credibly engage in an investigation of atrocities in Syria given his alleged connection to human-rights abuses in his own country.

Al-Dabi reported this past week that he had seen “nothing frightening” in the embattled Syrian city of Homs. Yet, if the reports can be taken as accurate, 150 more protesters have been killed on Syria’s streets since the observers arrived. Even the advisory committee to the Arab League has opined that the monitors come home.


Related: Jennifer Welsh’s assessment of NATO action in Libya.


So how are we to judge the effectiveness of this effort to change the behaviour of the Syrian government? If we use short-term measures, we might conclude that the observers’ success in facilitating the delivery of food supplies and the removal of dead protesters has had some concrete, positive effect. It’s also likely that the presence of a mission from the outside world has emboldened the protest movement, and given it hope.

But in the longer term, as the International Crisis Group’s Peter Harling recently argued on BBC Radio 4, we are witnessing a tug-of-war in Syria that has an uncertain end. The same observers who verify protesters’ assertions that they are being massacred also bear witness to what the regime wants them to see: an armed struggle, in which Syrian security forces are also being killed. The Assad government’s narrative – that it is facing a well-organized and externally resourced insurgency – may also be bolstered by the mission’s reports.

More broadly, the monitoring mission calls into question the relationship between regional and global organizations. Throughout the Syrian crisis, there have been calls for the UN Security Council to authorize coercive measures to prevent further atrocities. There are a variety of reasons this global body has not done so, including the likelihood of a veto from one of its permanent members. But it has also been argued that regional organizations, closer to the events on the ground, should take the first steps. And we are reminded that without an explicit request from the Arab League, the council would never have authorized NATO to use “all necessary measures” to prevent the slaughter of civilians in Libya (partly out of fear of being associated with a neo-colonial intervention). The consent of regional organizations, it seems, has become a necessary precondition for global action.

The original United Nations Charter, in Chapter VIII, envisaged a collective security architecture in which regional organizations would take the lead. Indeed, some scholars have long argued that collective security can only be regional, since it is simply not credible to ask countries from across the world to bring their military forces to bear on a security threat that does not directly affect them. Far better that those who are closer – with special historical ties, the capacity to act quickly, and intimate knowledge of the neighbouring country’s political dynamics – take on the responsibility of addressing instability in their neighbourhood.

While these arguments about a link between vicinity and responsibility make some sense, there are also important drawbacks to relying on regional partners as first movers. Although they undoubtedly have more at stake, they may also have an interest in a particular outcome – one that advantages them. There is also the possibility that “historical ties” have not always been amicable. In some regions, there are particular hegemons – South Africa or Nigeria in Africa, for example, or the United States in the western hemisphere – that are viewed with suspicion. Using this logic, a global organization, without a particular axe to grind, would be viewed as more impartial and therefore more legitimate.


Related: Roland Paris considers a new grand strategy for the new world disorder.


More recently, an additional issue has arisen with respect to regional organizations. Let’s call it the “capacity problem.” It may be fine for the UN Security Council to call upon players in the region to act first, as it did when it asked the African Union to take the lead in the crisis in Darfur in 2004-5. But what happens when such organizations do not have the resources (financial or human) to do so? In this instance, deferring to regional organizations risks looking like avoiding responsibility rather than delegating it. Yes, the United Nations eventually joined forces with the African Union in Darfur – to create a hybrid mission – but this was only after two years of further struggle and countless more civilian deaths.

In Syria, there are too few Arab League monitors in too few places. Even if more are dispatched, it is worth asking whether this regional organization, on its own, has the capacity and authority to facilitate a solution to this intractable struggle. The UN – with all the baggage it carries and all the suspicion it engenders – may still prove itself indispensable.

This article was originally published for the Canadian International Council's Roundtable Blog.

Photo courtesy of Reuters.

2011 in Review: Best TV Shows


Cable television continued to be the most fertile ground for shows this year, with AMC, HBO, and FX all producing series that redefined what being a TV show means. What was your favourite show?
Did we miss your favourite TV show? Tell us about it in the comments section below!

More from The Mark’s '2011 in Review' series:
1. Best in Science and Technology
2.Best Political Blunder
3.Best Books
4.Best Films

Thursday, January 5, 2012

How SOPA Will Change the Internet

AppId is over the quota
AppId is over the quota
type="html">

There has been an immense amount of talk lately regarding a bill currently making its way through the U.S. Congress known as the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA). SOPA has been fashioned as an effective response to rampant online piracy of copyrighted content by granting the attorney general broad and sweeping powers to attack infringing websites. The law also gives individual rights-holders a new procedure complete with remedies they’ve never had access to before.

The bill is a companion to the equally controversial Protect IP Act, also being debated in Congress. These two bills signify a sharp change in the American copyright landscape, specifically as it pertains to the Internet.

In addition to granting the attorney general the power to obtain a court order against a site that is either “committing or facilitating online piracy,” the attorney general may also order third-party payment providers, such as Visa or PayPal, and online advertising networks to stop supporting and dealing with a site in question. Many sites that host audio and video content rely on advertizing dollars to function. Simillarly, any site that requires a paid membership would be completely ship-wrecked without online payment solutions such as PayPal or Google Checkout to process those fees.


Related: Collusion and Collision in Internet Censorship

Furthermore, the attorney general may order the de-indexing of allegedly infringing sites from search engines. Many have likened this rather extreme measure to the Internet censorship protocols, known colloquially as the "Great Firewall,” enacted by the Chinese government. While this may be an extreme appraisal, this measure brings up significant free speech issues.

As mentioned above, not only the attorney general but also regular rights holders have been given powerful enforcement tools. If a rights holder (such as a movie studio or music publisher) believes a site is infringing their copyright, they must undertake a two-step process. First, they must contact payment providers and advertising networks doing business with the site in question. Upon forwarding them a complaint, the aledgedly infringing site are to cease their service in relation to the website and forward the complaint to the owner of the domain. At this point, the site owner must reply and explain how their activities are not infringing copyright (e.g., the material is legally licensed, fair use, etc.). If they do not, the rights holder may apply to a court for a limited injunction on the website.

SOPA tries to incentivize the voluntary compliance of advertisement and payment networks by extending them immunity from liability if they "squeal" on an instance of copyright piracy or trademark infringement.

Finally, the bill expands the penalties related to certain activities, including streaming video and various instances of counterfeiting. For example, SOPA provides for criminal sactions against those who infringe by streaming copyrighted content. While he may not have wanted to be the poster boy for the anti-SOPA plight, many point out that Justin Biber could very well have been put in jail for streaming himself singing copyright protected songs (without authorization). Another example could be an Olympic athlete who puts a video of his or her ski run or dive online for fans to view. Surely the intention of Congress could not stretch to such benign and (seemingly) morally justifiable actions?

Supporters of the bill tout it as the weapon American rights holders need to effectively police their IP rights. Supporting organizations include the obvious players, such as the Recoding Industry Association of America (RIAA) and the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA), as well as large commercial entities like Nike, Ford, and Pfizer. SOPA would presumably make it easier for those large entities to enforce their trademark rights, adding to the ICANN Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP). While the latter only allows rights holders to go after infringing domain names , SOPA would allow them to pursue websites that make use of their trademarks in the actual content of the site itself, that is to say instances of trademark use anywhere on the web site.

Detractors contend that the bill is an outrage and must be killed immediately. Representatives on both sides of the House have been outspoken critics, among them Rep. Nancy Pelosi and current Republican nominee for presidential candidacy Rep. Ron Paul. In Rep. Paul’s own words, SOPA will likely result in "an explosion of innovation-killing lawsuits and litigation.”

Some even question the efficacy of the bill. Sure, the attorney general may ban sites from the American web, but the domain-name system (DNS) can be manipulated in creative ways to circumvent this roadblock. As was bore witness to during this year's Arab Spring, people can use mirror and proxy servers to get around national quarantines of the Internet.


Related: A Common Approach to Intellectual Property

The advent of these new measures also brings into question the utility of the Digital Millenium Copyright Act (DMCA)'s notice and take-down system. If SOPA passes, it will create a far stronger mechanism than what the DMCA currently offers. Unfortunately, the DMCA notice and take-down represents a significantly more balanced approach to dealing with piracy on the Internet than does the potentially ex parte (legal jargon meaning a hearing absent one of the parties) process put in place by SOPA. SOPA allows actions to be taken against the infringing site itself if the attorney general is unable to locate the owner of the site. This is highly significant as one of the fundamental principles of natural justice is the maxim “Audi Alterem Partem” (literally meaning “hear the other side”). This principle prevents a judgment from being rendered against someone without them either being present or at least having the opportunity to submit an argument in their own favor. SOPA (and Protect IP) allow for an action In Rem (against the property itself).

It remains to be seen what type of effect SOPA and Protect IP will have on the Internet landscape in the United States. The question also beckons as to whether any other countries will follow suit with national legislation of their own in the same vein. Being the world’s largest exporter of intellectual property, the United States has a vested interest in seeing IP laws around the world tighten. Here in Canada, our Copyright Modernization Act, currently making its way through Parliament, seems to already reflect that exported interest. The last thing Canada needs right now is “SOPA North.” However, since “Stephen” and “Barack” are such good buddies these days, who knows what could happen.